Best Bakery Brooklyn

If one thing is for certain, the food in New York is one of its biggest attractions, and the Big Apple isn’t short of delicious bakeries.

In fact, Brooklyn is home to some of the best bakeries in the whole of New York City! 

Whether you’re planning on staying in Brooklyn or have recently moved to the area, you might be curious to know what the best bakeries in Brooklyn are.

In this article, I will cover 10 of the best bakeries in Brooklyn, so whether you’ve moved there or are simply visiting, you know which are the best places to visit.

So, let’s get started. 

Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop

727 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222-7026

If you’re in the mood for a sweet treat, then Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop in Brooklyn is definitely worth checking out.

Having been open for over 60 years, Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop is a family owned and operated business that has a wide and very delicious variety of baked goods. 

Hailed for their fresh donuts, some of the most popular flavors include:

  • Red Velvet
  • Blueberry Buttermilk
  • Chocolate Cake
  • Boston Cream
  • Sour Cream Glazed
  • Apple Crumb

However, they don’t just serve mouthwateringly sweet donuts. They also have a large variety of pastries, sandwiches, breakfast platters, bagels, rolls, flagels, croissants, and more.

In addition to their delicious baked goods, Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop serves an array of hot and cold beverages to accompany your food of choice.

If that wasn’t enough to tempt you next time you’re exploring the streets of Brooklyn, you should know that they have seasonal specials that vary depending on the season when you visit. Whether it’s winter, spring, summer or autumn, there is sure to be an option to suit everyone. 

Martha’s Country Bakery

263 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211-4010

Martha’s Country Bakery is another great choice in Brooklyn if you’re looking to indulge.

Established in 1972, they have multiple stores all over New York, with two located in Brooklyn.

All of the treats at Martha’s Country Bakery are baked on-site, meaning that every time you visit you’re hit with the delicious, comforting smell of freshly baked goods.

It’s easy to feel spoiled for choice when visiting Martha’s. This bakery is full of delicious cakes, from delicately decorated cupcakes to large, indulgent celebration cakes that are perfect for any special occasion. 

In addition to this, they serve cake pops, cheesecakes, pastries, puddings, pies, cookies, muffins, gelato and sorbet. 

Whether you’re looking to sit and warm up on a cold winter’s day, or simply want an iced coffee to go during the summer, you’re bound to feel satisfied with their expertly roasted and richly brewed coffee every time. They serve a variety of teas, and for hot chocolate lovers, this is the place to be. From hot chocolate to Mexican hot chocolate, red velvet and peanut butter hot chocolate, it doesn’t get much better than this!


85 Water St, Brooklyn, NY 11201-1092

Almondine is a traditional French bakery that is sure to impress you if you’re in the Brooklyn area or are looking for somewhere delicious to visit.

From the French classics of croissants and pastries, to the more delicate fruit tarts and eclairs made from choux dough and filled with rich crème pâtissière, Almondine is the perfect place to grab a bite to eat when you’re close to the Brooklyn bridge. 

If you’d rather something savory, Almondine’s freshly baked bread, baguettes, and sandwiches are equally as delicious to enjoy as a first course before you enjoy a sweet treat.

Bakeries that produce their baked goods on-site are becoming harder to find, let alone finding bakeries that are always as reliable as Almondine’s treats. 

Almondine serves a variety of hot drinks to keep you warm on your walk to the nearby park or over the Brooklyn bridge. From coffee and tea to their deliciously rich and indulgent hot chocolates, there really isn’t a better place to curl up with a book and get a taste of France!


150 Wythe Ave Between 8th St And 7th St, Brooklyn, NY 11249-2855

Established in 2009, Bakeri is a women-owned bakery with a cozy feel that feels like a warm hug every time you step in.

With two stores in Brooklyn to choose from, Bakeri offers a wealth of baked goods to browse. While their freshly baked bagels, baguettes, and breads might take your fancy, they also offer warm, mouth watering pastries such as croissants, pain au chocolats, and tarts.

Bakeri even has a catering menu to help make a variety of different occasions easier for you. From birthday parties, to weddings and photoshoots, you can order a selection of their foods and get it delivered if you spend a minimum of $200.

Their breakfast options include a pastry basket with an array of delicious beverages, while their lunch menu includes boxed lunches and a variety of freshly made sandwiches and salads if you’re looking for a healthier alternative.

They also have several cookies and bite-sized bars to satiate your sweet tooth, as well as coffee that serves ten to twelve people. For parties of 10 or more, they ask that you order with 48 hours notice.

Mia’s Bakery

139 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11201-7732

If you’re looking to indulge, then Mia’s Bakery should be another bakery to tick off your list when you’re exploring the streets of Brooklyn.

From freshly baked pies and enticing pastries, to intricately designed and decorated cakes, Mia’s offer special treats that are suitable for every occasion.

You only need to look at their gallery to see how much care and attention Mia’s Bakery pays to every single celebration cake, no matter the event. From delicate fondant designs, to indulgent cream cakes, there isn’t anything that they can’t achieve. 

The Mia’s Bakery website even offers you the option to customize the perfect cake for a loved one’s special occasion. In this section, you can detail exactly what they would like and can even upload a picture to provide the bakery with a specific design to replicate.

If you’d rather simply pop in for a hot beverage, Mia’s Bakery offers several different beverages, from coffee to silky hot chocolates that are the perfect accompaniment to any baked treat.

With locations in Brooklyn and Times Square, you have no excuse but to check Mia’s Bakery out next time you’re in the city!

Dun-Well Doughnuts

222 Montrose Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11206-2353

If you’re a vegan and are on the lookout for the best donuts in Brooklyn, then look no further than Dun-Well Doughnuts.

Dun-Well offers a variety of artisanal doughnuts that are handcrafted on a daily basis with the highest quality ingredients. If you’re looking for your caffeine fix, they also offer a barista menu with several delicious coffees that are sure to help you start your day in the best way.

All of Dun-Well’s baked goods and products are free of animal or animal derived ingredients, meaning that they have become somewhat of a hotspot for vegans and vegetarians alike. 

You won’t believe how delicious these doughnuts taste! What Dun-Well eliminate in terms of dairy and animal products, they make up for in taste. 

In addition to this, Dun-Well pride themselves on being ethically minded and are heavily committed to sourcing quality ingredients and supporting local businesses in the process. 

Dun-Well Doughnuts has space and tables to eat in. So, whether you’re grabbing a bite to eat on your commute or have more time to kill, there’s an option to suit everyone.

Doughnut Plant – Downtown Brooklyn

245 Flatbush Ave Prospect Heights, Brooklyn, NY 11217-2457

Sticking in line with the doughnuts theme, you can’t explore Brooklyn without paying a visit to Doughnut Planet. With seven stores to choose from in the whole of the city, you really can’t go wrong with the beautifully buttery and soft doughnuts from this wonderful bakery.

Planet Doughnut has an array of mouth watering doughnuts, from standard doughnuts, to cake doughnuts, and sour doughnuts. Their classic doughnuts, such as their sprinkle mini yeast doughnuts and their vanilla bean doughnuts are crowd favorites. 

However, they also have seasonal specials that they switch out that are super popular, such as their apple cardamom cake doughnut and their peach cake doughnut. For a really indulgent treat, why not try their filled squares doughnut?

Having dietary requirements doesn’t automatically mean that you need to miss out on all of the fun, and Doughnut Planet recognizes this. As a result, they offer gluten-free and vegan doughnuts for people with allergies or those who follow a plant-based or vegan diet.

You can even order online and order ahead along with your morning cup of coffee if you’d prefer not to wait in the queue!

Monteleone’s, 355 Court St

Brooklyn, NY 11231-4332

Monteleone’s is a traditional Sicilian bakery located in the heart of Brooklyn. If you’re in search of a sweet treat that keeps the Sicilian tradition alive, then Montelone’s is the place to visit.

This bakery has a variety of sweet treats for you to try, from gelato on a hot summer’s day to beautifully decorated tortes. They also pride themselves on their traditional desserts, including beautiful cakes and tarts decorated with gorgeous fresh fruit, to decadent chocolate desserts that you’re sure to dream about for weeks afterwards.

For a special occasion, you need a special occasion cake! Montelone’s also offers a variety of custom cakes that are perfect for any occasion, from creative fondant designs to beautifully piped icing. Whether you have a birthday or a wedding coming up, they know exactly how to impress a crowd.

Whether you want a sweet treat or the delicious taste of Italian coffee, Monteleone’s is the perfect bakery to visit for a truly authentic experience.

The Bagel Store, 69 5th Ave

Brooklyn, NY 11217-4650

If you want to add a dash of color to a grey day in Brooklyn, then The Bagel Store is another fabulous bakery to check out. Known for their infamous rainbow bagels that took the internet by storm, this isn’t a bakery or an eating experience that you’re likely to forget about any time soon.

In fact, tourists travel far and wide to snap an Instagram of these aesthetically pleasing and equally as delicious bagels. That’s got to count for something, right? Not to mention, your kids will absolutely love them!

The Bagel Store allows you to choose from a variety of different bagels and different fillings. From savory fillings like cream cheese to their signature bacon, egg, & cheese bagel or sweet fillings such as their over the rainbow bagel with rainbow-fetti sprinkles cake-cream cheese or Nutella, the options are nearly endless!

The Bagel Store also offers a catering menu with some of their favorites, including the Original Rainbow Bagel Cotton Candy Bagel Platter and Coffee Joe to go. In addition to this, they also offer cold cut platters with a selection of delicious cold meats and cheeses.

Jacques Torres Chocolate

66 Water St, Brooklyn, NY 11201-1135

If you’re a big fan of chocolate, then you simply can’t miss the opportunity to miss Jacque Torres Chocolate. Often hailed as being Mr. Chocolate, Jacques Torres fulfilled his American dream in 2000 with the opening of his first chocolate store and factory in Brooklyn.

Jacques Torres Chocolate specializes in fresh, handcrafted chocolates that are made using premium ingredients free of preservatives and artificial flavors. 

As the place where it all started, the store offers truffles to baked cookies to bonbons and more! For any chocolate lover, you really can’t go wrong with enjoying these heavenly delights.

With 7 stores to choose from throughout New York City, you have no excuse to not swing by. You can even sample your favorite flavors to bring home and share with your whole family. Trust me, they’ll thank you for it later.

In summary 

So, there you have it! Some of the best bakeries in Brooklyn, New York. I hope you enjoy your stay and eat plenty of baked goods!